LMTD Calculation for Heat Exchangers: Correction Factor F and Shell-and-Tube Sizing Worked Example
Every shell-and-tube exchanger is sized against one number: the mean temperature difference that drives heat across the tubes. The log mean temperature difference, with a correction factor for multi-pass layouts, is the standard way to get it. This post answers the five questions engineers search for most, then sizes a one-shell-pass, four-tube-pass oil cooler step by step. It builds on our overview of heat exchangers.

When to use the LMTD method?
Use the LMTD method when the inlet and outlet temperatures of both streams are known or fixed by the process, and the unknown is the area. That is the normal situation in exchanger design: the duty Q follows from the flow, specific heat and temperature change, and the area from Q = U A F ΔTlm. When the outlet temperatures are unknown, as when rating an existing exchanger, the NTU method is easier, because it works from the effectiveness and the number of transfer units, NTU = U A / Cmin, without iteration. The two methods give the same answer, so many designers use LMTD to size and NTU to check off-design performance. A spreadsheet or LMTD calculator handles the arithmetic.
Can you explain what LMTD is and how it is used in heat exchangers?
The logarithmic mean temperature difference is the average driving force between the hot and cold streams over the whole exchanger. The difference between the streams changes along the length, so an arithmetic mean overstates it; the log mean, ΔTlm = (ΔT1 − ΔT2) / ln(ΔT1 / ΔT2), is exact for constant U and specific heats. ΔT1 and ΔT2 are the end differences, and they depend on the flow arrangement: in counter-current flow the hot inlet faces the cold outlet, while in parallel flow it faces the cold inlet. Counter-current flow gives the larger mean difference, so it needs less area. In design, ΔTlm combines with U, which comes from the film coefficients in our convective heat transfer post, and with the correction factor F for real exchanger layouts.
What is the formula for calculating the correction factor for LMTD in the heat exchanger formula?
Real exchangers are rarely pure counter-current. Multi-pass shell-and-tube units and cross flow arrangements have a lower effective difference than the counter-current logarithmic mean temperature difference, and the correction factor F, between 0 and 1, accounts for it: Q = U A F ΔTlm. For one shell pass and two or more even tube passes, F depends on two ratios, with hot-side temperatures T and cold-side temperatures t:
P = (t2 − t1) / (T1 − t1) and R = (T1 − T2) / (t2 − t1)
F = [√(R²+1) / (R−1)] × ln[(1−P) / (1−PR)] / ln{ [2 − P(R+1−√(R²+1))] / [2 − P(R+1+√(R²+1))] }
For R = 1 a limiting form applies. F equals 1 for pure counter-current flow and for a stream that changes phase at constant temperature, such as condensing steam. The same results appear on factor graphs in TEMA and heat transfer texts, one chart per shell pass arrangement, and the formula lets a spreadsheet do the same job. As a rule, a design with F below about 0.8 is poor and often needs a different arrangement, such as more shells in series.
What does a high LMTD mean?
A high LMTD means a large average temperature difference between the streams, so for a given duty and U the exchanger needs less area and costs less. Equivalently, a given area will transfer more heat. The benefit has limits: large differences raise the wall temperature on the hot side, which can foul or degrade the fluid, and they increase thermal stress at the tubesheet. In energy terms a high LMTD also means more irreversibility, since heat falls across a large temperature gap. Compare it with the effectiveness from the NTU method when the choice is between more area and a higher driving force.
How to calculate the LMTD?
Follow four steps. First list the four temperatures. Second find the end differences for the flow arrangement: for counter-current flow, ΔT1 = Th,in − Tc,out and ΔT2 = Th,out − Tc,in. Third apply the logarithmic mean. Fourth multiply by F for multi-pass layouts. In Excel, with ΔT1 in B1 and ΔT2 in B2, use =IF(ABS(B1-B2)<0.001,B1,(B1-B2)/LN(B1/B2)); the IF avoids a divide-by-zero when the two differences are equal, where the log mean equals either one. Both end differences must be positive for the equation to work.
Worked Example: Sizing an Oil Cooler
A shell-and-tube oil cooler must remove 800 kW. Oil (cp = 2.1 kJ/kg·K, 6.35 kg/s) flows on the shell side from 150 °C to 90 °C. Cooling water on the tube side is heated from 30 °C to 50 °C. Take an overall U = 300 W/m²K, which includes fouling, with one shell pass and four tube passes.
| Step | Calculation | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Counter-current end differences | 150 − 50 and 90 − 30 | 100 K and 60 K |
| LMTD | (100 − 60) / ln(100/60) | 78.3 K |
| Parallel flow, for comparison | 120 K and 40 K: 80 / ln 3 | 72.8 K |
| P and R | (50 − 30) / (150 − 30); (150 − 90) / (50 − 30) | P = 0.167, R = 3.0 |
| Correction factor | formula above | F = 0.966 |
| Required area | 800,000 / (300 × 0.966 × 78.3) | 35.3 m² |
| With 15% margin | 35.3 × 1.15 | 40.5 m² |
| Tubes (19.05 mm OD, 4.0 m) | 40.5 / (π × 0.01905 × 4.0) | 169, use 172 |
| Water flow | 800 / (4.18 × 20) | 9.57 kg/s |
| Tube velocity | 0.00965 m³/s / (43 × 1.95 × 10⁻⁴ m²) | 1.15 m/s |
F = 0.966 is comfortably above the usual 0.8 minimum. The 172 tubes of 19.05 mm OD (15.75 mm ID) and 4.0 m effective length give 41.2 m², a margin of 16.8% over the required area. Four passes lift the tube velocity to 1.15 m/s; two passes would give only 0.58 m/s, too low for cooling water, which is why the pass count was raised. The shell diameter follows from the tube count and pitch in the TEMA layout tables, and pressure drop on both sides must still be checked.
Practical Checks
- Temperature cross: F falls quickly when the cold outlet approaches the hot outlet, so add shells in series if F drops below about 0.8.
- Fouling: include fouling resistances in U, using project data or TEMA guidance, and keep a margin on area.
- Velocity and pressure drop: check both sides, since low tube velocity fouls and high velocity erodes.
- Thermal expansion: fixed-tubesheet exchangers see differential expansion between tubes and shell, so check whether an expansion joint is needed.
- Mechanical design: shell and channel thickness follow ASME VIII Division 1 and TEMA rules; see our shell thickness calculation post and the wider pressure vessel design guide.
- Final rating: confirm the hand calculation in rating software before fabrication.
How Fluxiss Approaches Heat Exchanger Design
Fluxiss is a multidisciplinary engineering consultancy serving oil and gas, power and maritime clients. Its pressure vessel design service covers the mechanical design of heat exchangers alongside nozzles, supports and piping loads.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is LMTD valid when U changes along the exchanger?
Only approximately. The derivation assumes constant U and specific heats, so for large variations divide the exchanger into zones.
What if ΔT1 equals ΔT2?
The log mean equals either value, so use that value directly to avoid a divide-by-zero.
Does F apply to condensers?
No. F = 1 when one stream stays at constant temperature, such as condensing steam, because R is zero.
Which is better, LMTD or NTU?
Both give the same answer. LMTD suits sizing with known temperatures, and NTU suits rating when outlet temperatures are unknown.
Need heat exchanger and pressure vessel design support?
Fluxiss provides pressure vessel design for oil and gas, power and industrial projects, including shell-and-tube heat exchangers. Send your duty and process data, and the team can advise on the design basis.
Comments
Post a Comment
Questions or corrections are welcome. Please mention the relevant section and units. Do not post confidential project data or personal contact details. For project inquiries, use the Fluxiss contact page.